Why your wide shoes still squash your toes
| Mary & Georgi - Roam Barefoot
Always searching for shoes wide enough?
If you have spent years buying "wide fit" shoes and your toes still feel squashed, the problem probably isn't the width of your foot. It's the shape of the shoe.
We hear this all the time. Recently we met a runner who had never heard of barefoot shoes. She told us she was forever searching for wide running shoes, because every pair felt too narrow and left her feet sore. She had tried the wide versions, sized up, and loosened the laces. Nothing quite worked.
If that sounds like you, read on. This article explains why most wide shoes still don't cut the mustard, the signs your shoes are too narrow, and a type of footwear you may not have come across: shoes shaped like an actual foot.
Why "wide fit" shoes still pinch your toes
Most wide-fit shoes add room across the whole shoe, but they keep the same tapered, pointed shape at the front. Your toes are still funnelled inwards towards the middle.
Stand barefoot and look down at your feet. For most people, the widest part is across the toes, not the ball of the foot. Your big toe naturally points straight ahead (though this may not be the case for you anymore if you've spent your whole life in shoes that taper at the toes). Now look at the outline of a typical shoe, even a sneaker. It comes to a point around the second toe, so the big toe and little toe get pushed inwards.
A wider version of that shoe makes the whole thing bigger, often including the heel and midfoot. That can leave your heel slipping while your toes are still squeezed at the front. It's just a bigger version of the wrong shape.
|
|
Standard shoe |
"Wide fit" shoe |
Foot-shaped (barefoot) shoe |
|
Toe box shape |
Tapers to a point |
Tapers to a point, slightly roomier |
Widest at the toes, follows the foot |
|
Where the extra room goes |
None |
Spread across the whole shoe |
Mainly at the toes |
|
Heel fit |
Snug |
Can be loose |
Snug |
|
Room for toes to spread |
Little |
Some |
Lots |
This is why many people with wide feet go round in circles. The search term they use is "wide shoes", when what their feet actually need is a wide toe box.
Signs your shoes are too narrow for your feet
Your shoes may be too narrow at the toes if you notice any of these:
- Toes that feel squashed, overlap or press against each other
- Rubbing, blisters or corns on the outside of your little toe or the side of your big toe
- Numbness, tingling or burning in your toes, especially later in the day or on a long walk or run
- Bruised or black toenails
- Pain across the ball of your foot
- Relief the moment you take your shoes off
- Red marks on your feet where the shoe has been pressing
- Sizing up just to get enough width, then finding the shoes too long
A quick test: take the insole out of your shoe and stand on it. If your toes spill over the edges, the shoe is narrower than your foot.
Persistent pain, numbness or changes in the shape of your feet are worth getting checked by a podiatrist or your GP.
Bunions and shoe shape
A bunion is a bony lump at the base of the big toe, where the toe leans in towards the others. According to Healthify NZ, bunions affect about 1 in 4 people and are more common in women and older people.
Shoes don't cure bunions, but shoes that leave room for your toes can make day-to-day life much more comfortable, and combined with foot exercises and using tools like toe spacers, you can straighten up your big toe a lot and have minimal or no pain anymore, though the bunion will still be there.
If you have a bunion, a shoe that tapers at the front presses right on the sore spot and actively pushes the big toe inwards. A foot-shaped toe box gives the joint and toes space instead. Many of our customers with bunions tell us it was the first time in years a shoe didn't rub.
Please see a podiatrist or your GP if a bunion is getting worse, stopping you from doing everyday things, or if you have diabetes.
Why running shoes so often feel too narrow
Running magnifies a narrow toe box, because your feet spread and swell with every step. When your foot lands and pushes off, your toes naturally splay out. Over a long run your feet also swell. A shoe that felt fine in the shop can feel tight by the 5 km mark.
That's why so many runners search for things like "running shoes too narrow", "toes numb when running" or "how to stop black toenails". The usual advice is to size up half a size and buy the wide version. That may help some people, but the toe box often still tapers, so the toes get squeezed and pushed forward on every stride.
Foot-shaped running shoes keep the toe area wide so your toes can spread when you land and push off. They usually have a thinner, more flexible sole and no raised heel, which brings us to barefoot shoes.
What are barefoot shoes?
Barefoot shoes are shoes designed around the natural shape and movement of your foot. Despite the name, you're not walking around barefoot. They come in everyday sneakers, boots, sandals, work shoes and running shoes, and many look like ordinary shoes.
They share four features:
- A wide, foot-shaped toe box. The front of the shoe follows the outline of your toes, so they can lie flat and spread.
- Zero drop. The heel and the front of the foot sit at the same height, with no raised heel. This helps with getting correct posture so you're not adjusting other parts of your body to account for your feet tipping forward.
- A thin, flexible sole. You can bend and twist the shoe, and your foot can move and feel the ground.
- Lightweight. Less shoe for your feet to carry around.
For people with wide feet, the toe box is often the big "aha" moment. Many find it's the first time their toes haven't been squeezed together in years.
Barefoot shoes are not the same as "comfort" or orthopaedic shoes, which usually rely on thick cushioning and built-in arch support. Barefoot shoes take the opposite approach: give the foot room and let it do its job. Feet are amazingly adaptable and are designed to support our bodies!
Ease in gradually, especially if you run
The toe room feels good straight away, but the thinner sole and flat heel can take time to get used to. If you've worn cushioned shoes with a raised heel for most of your life, your feet, calves and Achilles need time to adjust.
• Start by wearing your new shoes for short periods around home or on short walks, and build up over weeks.
• Runners: don't swap straight to barefoot shoes for your usual runs. Start with short, easy distances and keep your current shoes for the rest while you build up. Doing too much too soon is the most common way people get sore calves or injuries.
• Expect some muscle tiredness in your feet and calves at first. Sharp or lasting pain means back off.
Our free transition guide walks you through this step by step. If you have a foot condition, diabetes or are recovering from an injury, check with a health professional before you start.
Frequently asked questions
What's the difference between wide shoes and wide toe box shoes? Wide shoes are usually a wider version of a standard, tapered shoe. Wide toe box shoes are shaped so the widest part is at the toes, giving them room to spread while the heel stays snug.
Where can I buy wide toe box shoes in New Zealand? Roam Barefoot is a New Zealand online store specialising in barefoot shoes with foot-shaped toe boxes. We stock Be Lenka, Xero Shoes, PaperKrane and Lang.S, and offer personal fit advice before you buy.
Are barefoot shoes good for wide feet? For many people, yes. Most barefoot shoes have a much wider toe box than conventional shoes, and some styles and brands suit very wide or high-volume feet. Width, volume and shape varies between brands, so measure your feet and ask us before you buy.
Are barefoot shoes good for bunions? They won't make a bunion go away, but a wide toe box with no pointed front avoids pressing on the bunion. Health advice for bunions is to wear wide-toed shoes with a low heel and a soft sole, which describes most barefoot shoes. See a podiatrist if your bunion is painful or getting worse.
Can I run in barefoot shoes if my feet are wide? Yes, there are barefoot running shoes with roomy toe boxes. Build up slowly, because running in thin, flat shoes uses your feet and calves differently.
Why do my toes go numb in my shoes? One common cause is a toe box that's too narrow or too shallow, squeezing your toes and the nerves between them. If numbness continues even in roomier shoes, see a health professional.
Do barefoot shoes look strange? There's no doubt many barefoot shoes will look strange at first because we're so used to conventional shoes looking a particular way. There are some styles that still look very much like "normal" sneakers, boots or sandals though, it depends on the brand and the exact style. Most of our customers are surprised at how quickly they get used to the new look though, and quickly start to think that their old shoes look strange!
Where to start
If you've been searching for wide shoes for years, try looking for a wide toe box instead. Here's how to begin with us:
- Measure your feet. Length and width, in centimetres. Our measuring guide shows you how.
- Read up on transitioning. Our free transition guide explains how to ease in.
- Browse by activity. Take a look through the menu at the top of our website or simply type into the search bar what you're after.
- Ask us. Not sure which brand suits wide or high-volume feet? Send us your measurements through the "Ask a question" form on any product page and we'll help you choose.
Roam Barefoot is a small New Zealand business started by two people who discovered barefoot shoes for their own feet and families. Making barefoot shoes accessible to Kiwis is what we're all about, and we're always happy to help.
Leave a comment
Your email address will not be published.